Former Liverpool defender Steve Nicol has identified two critical hurdles that Liam Rosenior must overcome as he prepares to succeed Enzo Maresca as Chelsea’s head coach. Reports indicate that the London club is finalizing a deal for the 41-year-old following Maresca’s departure last Thursday due to escalating friction with the board.
Rosenior currently serves as the manager of Strasbourg, a French Ligue 1 side also owned by the BlueCo investment group, making his transition to Stamford Bridge a high-profile internal promotion within the multi-club ownership structure.
Nicol, speaking as a pundit on ESPN, cautioned the Englishman that the move represents a significant step up in both institutional demands and external expectations. He suggested that the primary reason for Maresca’s exit involved a lack of autonomy over sporting decisions, a dynamic he believes Rosenior will also have to navigate. Nicol argued that any successful manager must retain final authority over team selection and in-game adjustments, regardless of boardroom preferences.
“There’s a problem — you’re going to have to follow the instructions. Liam Rosenior has to follow the instructions he’s given. It’s pretty obvious that’s why Enzo Maresca isn’t there. If there is one thing you must be in charge of as the head coach or the manager, whatever you want to call it, it is when it comes down to the football. Who is playing, who isn’t playing, who is coming on and who is going off. You need to take responsibility for that. All the other things you can accept, but it definitely seems like that was Maresca’s problem,” Nicol stated.
The pundit further elaborated that the Chelsea ownership might view Rosenior’s relative youth and existing ties to BlueCo as qualities that make him more receptive to their guidance. However, Nicol warned that a willingness to defer to owners on tactical matters could undermine a manager’s professional integrity.
“Any coach who really cares about their job, if they can’t do those things, then I’m sorry. No. It’s a good appointment for Chelsea’s top team because he’s young and they can guide him on what to do. I don’t know if he will improve Chelsea, but he’s going to be told what to do, and that’s a really bad way to start. Any manager who goes into a job thinking they can always pick and choose who plays and who doesn’t is someone who doesn’t have self-respect,” Nicol added.
Beyond the internal politics, Nicol emphasized that the intense scrutiny at Stamford Bridge differs vastly from the environment at the Stade de la Meinau. Rosenior enjoyed a highly successful tenure in France, guiding Strasbourg to a seventh-place finish last season and an unbeaten run in the UEFA Conference League group stage. Despite these achievements, Nicol believes the requirement for immediate results at Chelsea poses a far greater threat to job security.
“Another issue he’ll face is pressure. Maresca was under pressure after losing a couple of games. That’s the difference between managing Strasbourg and managing Chelsea. Your job is to win. That’s a different situation,” Nicol concluded.
Rosenior arrives at a club that currently sits fifth in the Premier League and remains active in multiple cup competitions. He is expected to lead the team during Wednesday’s West London derby against Fulham at Craven Cottage. Fans will watch closely to see if the former Hull City boss can maintain his tactical identity while satisfying the rigorous demands of the Chelsea hierarchy.
About the Author
