The Osun State chapter of the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) has called on the Chief Judge of the Federal High Court (FHC) to probe the circumstances surrounding a controversial letter dated September 2, 2025, allegedly issued from his office in connection with the lingering local government fund crisis in the state.
The letter purportedly directed that a case before a vacation judge be heard by that judge substantively even after the vacation.
Addressing a press conference in Osogbo on Thursday, the state PDP chairman, Hon. Sunday Bisi, said the letter was signed not by a judge but by an unidentified individual on behalf of a personal aide of the Chief Judge. He described the letter and its circumstances as “a bizarre and unprecedented abuse of judicial process.”
According to the PDP, the suspicious letter was written despite the fact that no party before the court had applied for such a transfer.
The party also alleged that the letter may have been backdated to achieve political ends, warning that such action, if confirmed, would amount to a grievous injury on the nation’s judicial integrity.
The PDP chairman said that was the second letter that would be issued on that case by non-judicial officers who claimed to be working in the office of the Chief Judge.
“We are calling for nothing less than a thorough probe of those letters. Assignment of cases is a judicial decision. Judicial powers can not be exercised by proxies or by personal assistants. They are reserved exclusively for judicial officers (judges). Unfortunately, that is the abnormal situation we are confronted with and which informed this press conference.
“On the 21st of August, 2025, a letter was issued and signed by one Joshua Ibrahim Aji, Esq., who described himself as Special Assistant to the Honourable Chief Judge of the Federal High Court. In that letter, judicial functions were purportedly exercised, assigning a judicial duty to a judge of the court. This is a gross aberration. A Special Assistant is not a judicial officer, and judicial powers cannot be exercised either directly or by delegation through such an aide.
“To make matters worse, another letter emerged dated 2nd September, 2025. That one was not even signed by the so-called Special Assistant. It was signed by an unknown, unnamed individual, on behalf of the Special Assistant. The letter purported to assign a case to a judge, something that can never lawfully be done by anyone other than a judicial officer.
“Even more suspicious is that the letter was delivered to the Osun State counsel on the 11th of September, 2025, more than a week after it was purportedly signed. We have every reason to suspect that that letter may have been backdated to achieve political ends. This suspicion is strong because when the case came up on September 8, 2025 in Abuja, neither the court nor the party to which it was addressed spoke about the letter. This is bizarre, unprecedented, and unacceptable.
“The law is very clear. The power to transfer a matter from one judge of the Federal High Court to another is provided for under the Federal High Court Act. Such transfer can only be sought through a formal application, in open court, before the presiding judge handling the matter. It cannot be done through secret letters or shadowy signatures.
“In the 21st August letter, the office of the Chief Judge even suggested that the case would become ‘nugatory’ if not heard during vacation. But that is a question of fact and law that must be determined in open court with all parties heard. For an administrative letter to prejudge the issue shows bias and prejudice, and compromises the independence of the judiciary,” Osun PDP added.
According to the party, the abuse of power becomes even clearer when a September 2 letter was addressed directly to Chief Akin Olujinmi (SAN) counsel to the 3rd Defendant (the Attorney-General of the Federation) at a time when that defendant had already been withdrawn from the matter and had ceased to be a party in the case.
It maintained: “How can the office of the Chief Judge be writing letters to a party that had no proper process before the court? This is strange, bizarre, and deeply troubling. We are left to wonder: why is the office of the Chief Judge afraid to have this case heard in the Osogbo Division of the Federal High Court where it was filed? Why this backdoor manipulation of process by persons unknown to the law.
“Our position is clear: this matter must be returned to the regular Federal High Court in Osogbo. Any application for transfer must be made openly before the regular presiding judge. That is the law. Anything else is illegality.
“Let us also state clearly that the Honourable Attorney-General of the Federation is not innocent in this matter. The AGF has consistently disregarded the subsisting judgment of the Federal High Court in Suit No. FHC/OS/CS/103/2022 delivered on 30th November, 2022, which was affirmed by the Court of Appeal, Akure Division, in CA/AK/270/2025 delivered on 13th June, 2025. Instead of respecting these judgments, the AGF has been instigating manipulations against the people of Osun State and their duly elected PDP local government officials.
“The AGF’s actions keep suggesting to reasonable members of the public that he has effectively turned the Federal High Court into an annex of his Chambers. He has encouraged sacked APC Chairmen and Councillors to embark on reckless judicial adventures, seeking elongation of a tenure they never had. He has even filed a similar application before the Supreme Court,” the party in Osun state argued.
It noted that what the AGF initially sought through his counsel, Olujinmi, was only an expeditious hearing during vacation.
“That was the request. But by 2nd September, the story changed. Suddenly, a transfer directive was issued to a vacation judge, instructing him to act as a substantive judge, something no party had applied for. This is not a mere technicality. This is a deliberate attempt to erode judicial independence and impose political bias on the courts.
“We, the PDP in Osun State, therefore call on the Honourable Chief Judge of the Federal High Court to immediately probe these irregularities. He must investigate how and why persons, purportedly working in his office, who are not judicial officers, are signing letters that carry the force of judicial authority.We demand accountability. We demand transparency. Above all, we demand respect for the rule of law,” Bisi said.
Kayode Tokede
About the Author
