As the curtain begins to fall on Mohamed Salah’s illustrious nine-year tenure at Anfield, Liverpool icon Jamie Carragher has asserted that the Egyptian forward has officially overtaken Cristiano Ronaldo in the hierarchy of Premier League greats. In a recent editorial for The Telegraph, published in the wake of Salah’s emotional announcement that he will exit the club this summer, Carragher argued that the winger’s sustained brilliance places him in a rarified bracket of legendary imports. According to the pundit, only Arsenal’s Thierry Henry remains ahead of Salah when evaluating the most impactful foreign attackers to ever grace the English top flight.
The debate over Salah’s standing comes at a poignant moment, with the 33-year-old confirming that the 2025/26 campaign will be his final act in a Red shirt. While critics often point to the global stature of players like Ronaldo or the aesthetic genius of Eden Hazard and Dennis Bergkamp, Carragher maintains that none provided the relentless, year-on-year statistical dominance seen from Liverpool’s “number eleven.” By positioning Salah above a collection of the league’s most decorated icons—including Eric Cantona and Gianfranco Zola—Carragher highlights a career defined by an unprecedented level of durability and clinical execution.
Reflecting on the specific comparison to Manchester United’s former talisman, Carragher wrote:
“In the pantheon of overseas attacking players to have excelled in England, only Thierry Henry eclipses Salah. Ronaldo’s time at Manchester United, both initially and upon his return, was either side of his absolute, Real Madrid-peak years. Salah edges ahead of him when judging strictly on Premier League performance and impact.”
The numbers behind Carragher’s claim are undeniably staggering. Since his arrival on Merseyside from AS Roma in 2017 for what now looks like a bargain £34 million, Salah has rewritten the record books. His tally of 189 goals and 92 assists in the Premier League represents the highest total of goal involvements for any single player within that timeframe. This consistent output has been the engine behind Liverpool’s most successful modern era, yielding two Premier League titles and a Champions League trophy, and solidifying his place as the third-highest scorer in the club’s storied history.
As the Anfield faithful prepare for an emotional farewell tour leading up to the season’s conclusion in May, the conversation has shifted from Salah’s future to his permanent place in the annals of the game. Carragher’s assessment serves as a definitive tribute to a player who transformed the role of the modern wide attacker, evolving from a traditional winger into a goal-scoring phenomenon. With a potential move to the Saudi Pro League looming on the horizon for 2026/27, Salah leaves behind a legacy that, for many, has set a new gold standard for excellence in the Premier League.
About the Author
